Wednesday, October 08, 2008

You should read this because Brenner is so damned smart.

I'm not necessarily of the opinion that people read the comments on this blog, so I'm posting this one just left by Mike Brenner. Smarty. That's Brenner, pink hair and all:

Mike Brenner said...

the initial concept for the Cultural Alliance was an arts council for Milwaukee. the idea came from a very talented guy who moved to Milwaukee from out of state. he had been an active member of the arts council in Columbus. he was involved in all of the initial planning of the Cultural Alliance, but was convinced to leave the board so he'd be eligible to be hired as executive director. then the Cultural Alliance decided to grow to seven counties and include zoos and historical societies, and the job was given to the wife of some wealthy man who had a vested interest in the organization. the man who's brain child was the Cultural Alliance has since given up on Milwaukee and moved to Chicago.

there was also a point where i met with the Hertzfeld Foundation (a major supporter of the Cultural Alliance) to ask for funding for MARN. i was told MARN would never get a penny from the Hertzfeld Foundation unless we did all our programming under the name of the Cultural Alliance and met with their director (then Tony Forman) on a regular basis for guidance.

a lot of pressure was put on us to hand over our mailing list to the Cultural Alliance and to persuade our members to join their organization as well. i never saw the benefit for individual artists in doing that.

in the end, i gave up on MARN because the team of consultants we hired was told (earlier this year) that none of the funders in town would give money to MARN's arts incubator 'because of the failure of the Cultural Alliance.'

i guess my failure was my inability (lack of desire) to get the 'right' people on MARN's board. all i ever wanted to create was an organization for artists by artists that could be honest about our situation here and make things better for artists. unfortunately, there's very minimal financial support for organizations not run by Yes Men.

what i don't understand though, is how an organization, like the Cultural Alliance, that seems to be well funded, doesn't do anything that's apparent to any of us. to me it reads like an offshoot of UPAF... same funders, same administrators and serves the same organizations.

what they HOPE to do is great. if they do it, great. but until then Milwaukee remains one of the only major cities in America without a full-time (PAID) staff person working to make the arts a priority... which was what the Cultural Alliance was supposed to be in the first place when it was formed in 2003.

7 smart alecky remarks:

Rex Winsome said...

Let me get this straight: Funders gave the cultural alliance money. The cultural alliance did god knows what with that money. Then MARN who was doing what the cultural alliance should have been doing, but without any money asked the funders for money, and they were like: "no we already gave, to the Cultural Alliance, work with them" and then later they were all: "no, the cultural alliance failed, so we're not giving money to art's orgs".

Is that about right? Cuz then it seems to me that the best thing the cultural alliance can do for artists in milwaukee is shut their doors and get out of the way.

Christine Harris said...

As the Executive Director of the Cultural Alliance and having been a founding Board member, I am very dismayed at the numerous inaccuracies of Mike Brenner's comments. Mike was at the meeting that Jonathan held last week and never voiced any of these issues, commentary or questions. An opportunity was provided for full conversation and disclosure at Jonathan's request, so why post it on a blog without face to face conversation, Mike? Plus, you and I met some months ago, Mike, before you left MARN and you didn't raise any of these issues you are now posting. It is so much easier to throw out critique than sit face to face to sort out what is true and what is not, and then work together for the better good. The Cultural Alliance has the beginnings of a good working relationship with Melissa at MARN and we look forward to supporting the arts sector well and being an effective community organization. We will be judged by the value of our services, the feedback from our membership and the willingness of the community to fund us.
Thank you for the opportunity, Jonathan, to have the open discussion.
Christine

Mike Brenner said...

I only know what I've experienced and what I've been told. If I'm wrong about how the Cultural Alliance was started, by all means, let's set the record straight.

To be honest, the only things that matter to me anyway are my interaction with Carmen and Laura at Hertzfeld and what my very expensive consultants told me about MARN's inability to receive funding for our arts incubator.

The Cultural Alliance is just another brilliant project from the folks (Spirit of Milwaukee) that brought us the Bronze Fonz anyway. All the same shimmer and all the same substance.

Rex Winsome said...

Jonathan!

Lets get that podcast up! i missed the meeting cuz i couldn't get out of my day job. I'd really like to hear the cultural alliance's side of this.

Bigdog said...

I love a good arts spat. Kind of like watching your two kids battle each other. Nobody's really got the stomach for a bitter fight. Just some sniping. I love it that Jonathan can facilitate such events.

Anonymous said...

I am wondering just what Nick will change about that!!

-Yours Truly
Heidi

Anonymous said...

Silas, who cares :D

-Best regards
Josefa